Now, Mr. Rakeysh Omprakash Mehra… I understand this is “inspired”
by a true story.. I also agree that Milkha’s story is truly inspiring, so why
did I come out of the theater 3+ hours later feeling not really inspired?
The movie begins with a tragedy.. We are told that Milkha Singh
who was the favorite to win the 400m mens event at the Rome Olympics in 1960,
unfortunately looked behind and gave away his lead in the final.. losing the
bronze in a photo-finish As he turns, we are shown blurry ghosts of his past..
This isn’t the first time he has heard the titular cry “Bhaag Milkha Bhaag”.
His first tragedy was the trauma surrounding partition. He grew up
to be robber of sorts, fell for a girl who wouldn't marry a goon. He joined
army to “become someone”. Harsh training, bullying and 2 fantastic coaches
later, he has the coveted “India ”
blazer. So when he goes to seek marital alliance of the girl he oh-so-loved,
he’s told she’s already married. Another tragedy.
He finds himself awestruck, lovestruck/lust-struck with a gori, in
his first Olympic appearance. However much he slaps himself staring at the
mirror, he is not to forgive or forget this tragedy. That triggers a dedicated
effort to break the 400m world record and the stage is set for Olympics 1960.
We are somehow narrated, that the baggage of the past lead to the
catastrophic loss that lead to public outrage and self denial – both an
inseparable reality for Milkha Singh. First thing first: As someone who gets
tired of running from my building to the main gate (my 400 meter run once a
week may be, when I am late to meet a colleague) – I feel dwarfed by Milkha
Singh. As someone who went to gym 2 times and felt it was too taxing, I feel
dwarfed by Farhan Akhtar, who has literally chiseled himself with a sculpting
knife to look this fit for this role.
So let me just stop and not get dwarfed by the personalities, and
just talk about my experience with the movie as a movie.
So there are moments, there is great music (the kind that makes me
wonder why we don’t hear more of the talented Shankar Ehsaan Loy trio), there
is a little bit of everything and yet the whole is not greater than the sum of
its parts.
If anything, the screenplay is over-thought and the movie
over-directed (if you know what I mean). While the premise was great, the story
was simple and neat, the presentation simply overpowers the message, which was
essentially a heartfelt, individual struggle. The director (and writer) is too
busy making it a non-linear film that has associative links to the three
timelines of the movie, that none of the three timelines really create an
impact. The director’s re-use of sepia tone for the past and speed blurs is so
Rang-de-basanti-isque that I was partly wishing I was watching that movie,
instead.
Of the three, the timeline of Milkha’s childhood creates the most
impactf. Personal lives affected by partition are portrayed with raw fervor and
the images of violence are stirring and scary. There is nothing very unique
about his young adulthood – for cinema, at least. The boy meets girl sequences,
the chori sequence and some random tomfoolery –
all simply giving us another facet of the Milkha Singh personality, but doing
nothing really to the movie itself. I honestly feel, that this timeline
could’ve been chopped off to a large extent to make the film somewhat smaller.
But then it is a biopic. Or is it? For the director puts in enough
commercial masala (save for an item number THANK GOD) to convince us this is
just another bollywood film. And I think that is where the film falters – in
trying to make up its mind on being entertaining, accurate and yet slick and
punchy, the subtle emotions of Milkha are lost.
Farhan Akhtar submits himself to physically transforming himself into
Milkha Singh. He looks every bit an athlete and perhaps outdoes the fitness
levels of a professional athlete, and gets a runners body-language pitch
perfect, even tries a Punjabi accent, but still somehow remains a Farhan Akhtar
and doesn't become a Milkha Singh– his emotional moments, comic timings and
dialogue deliovery are distinctively Farhan Akhtar, and not of the character he
embodies. So as much as I am proud of what he has done to look and be the part,
I am conscious I never forgot it was him. Which is not uncommon in bollywood, I
have learnt. Like a Shahrukh is a Shahruk and a Salman is a Salman in every
film. But I honestly don’t think the makers and the actor (who both represent a
promising body of work) set those to be their benchmark.
Pawan Singh as the army coach and Prakash Raj as the accented
trainer are the only supporting cast that leave a mark. Oh, and Divya Dutta
hams (like it was a 50’s movie and not a movie set in the 50’s) and Sonam
Kapoor I am told took 11 rupees for the movie (that girl is so overpaid!).
Everything said and done, this is NOT a BADmovie. It is long, it
is entertaining in parts and has inspiring moments. If you are a Farhan Akhtar
fan, you MUST watch it. If you are into biopics, you MAY like it, if you go in expecting
some Rang de Basanti class of entertainment, just rent the RDB DVD, this one
will do nothing to you.
2.5 Stars. If it wasn’t for Farhan’s hardwork and the stellar
soundtrack, there wouldn’t be much to write home about.
Agree to most of the part but somehow I felt the real milkha must have been like this.
ReplyDeleteThere is nothing to get greatly excited about the story. You enjoy some of the light moments and you feel sad for some of the tragic moments. Rest is like reading a Wikipedia profile of a sports star. . . is what I felt
Yep. I agree. The personality of milkha is fine. I just couldn't connect to his emotions as much as I'd gave liked to.
Delete